Tengu vs PortfolioPilot: Advice That Acts vs Advice Alone

PortfolioPilot and Tengu both start around $20/month for AI portfolio analysis, then split completely. PortfolioPilot is deliberately advice-only, no execution, no conflicts, and on those terms it is one of the most credible products in AI investing. Tengu takes the opposite bet: advice that can act. Here is the honest comparison.

Try Tengu free Free to start · No card · Never custodial
25+ brokerages connectedExecutes only what you approveYour broker keeps custody
Tengu LearnUpdated 2026-06-12

What is PortfolioPilot?

PortfolioPilot (by Global Predictions) is an advice-only AI investing tool for self-directed investors. It aggregates your accounts read-only, analyzes your portfolio and net worth with hedge-fund-inspired models, and gives recommendations, deliberately without execution. Its pitch is conflict-free advice: no commissions, no order flow, no product to push. As of 2026 it reports 50,000+ users and tiers at Free, Gold ($20/mo), Platinum ($49/mo), and Pro (from $99/mo). On its own terms, it is good software.

What is Tengu?

Tengu is the AI portfolio manager that connects 25+ brokerages, including Robinhood, Schwab, Fidelity, Interactive Brokers, Coinbase, and Kraken, and executes the trades you approve through your own broker. Never custodial. Where PortfolioPilot stops at the recommendation, Tengu closes the loop: the same AI that researched the move can place it, through your own account, behind position-size limits, leverage caps, and drawdown circuit breakers. Tengu also runs a strategy marketplace (congressional trade tracking, 13F mirroring) and is building toward the full AI family office.

See it on your own portfolio: connect a broker and ask Tengu anything about your money.

Try Tengu free

Tengu vs PortfolioPilot: the comparison

PortfolioPilotTengu
Multi-account aggregationYes (read-only)Yes (read and trade)
AI research and recommendationsYesYes, with citations to filings and data
Executes tradesNo, by philosophyYes, through your own broker, with your approval
Automated strategiesNoYes (marketplace, incl. smart-money tracking)
Risk gates on ordersNot applicable (no orders)Position limits, leverage caps, drawdown breakers
CustodyNone (read-only)None (your brokers keep custody)
Entry priceFree; Gold $20/moFree; Chat $20/mo; Platform $149/mo

The real difference: what happens after the advice

Both products will tell you your portfolio is overweight tech, or that a position no longer fits your goals. With PortfolioPilot, you then open each brokerage app, find the position, size the order, and place it yourself, for every account, every time. With Tengu, you say yes, and the order routes through your own broker with the risk gates checking it on the way. The philosophical disagreement is real: PortfolioPilot argues that not executing keeps advice pure. Tengu argues that unexecuted advice decays into a to-do list, and that purity is preserved differently: no custody, no payment for order flow, flat subscription, and you approve everything. Advice without execution is a newsletter.

When PortfolioPilot is the right choice

If you want a second opinion on a portfolio you fully intend to manage by hand, and you prefer a tool that is structurally incapable of acting, PortfolioPilot's read-only model is exactly that, and its net-worth analytics are strong.

When Tengu is the right choice

Choose Tengu if you want the analysis and the follow-through: rebalancing that actually happens, strategies that run while you sleep, one AI accountable from research to fill. Same $20 entry price. The execution layer is the product.

Frequently asked questions

Are Tengu and PortfolioPilot the same price?

Both have free tiers and a $20/month entry tier. Tengu's full Platform with automated strategies and execution is $149/month; PortfolioPilot's higher tiers (Platinum $49, Pro from $99) add deeper analytics but still do not execute.

Does PortfolioPilot place trades?

No, deliberately. PortfolioPilot is advice-only by design and frames that as conflict-free. Tengu executes the trades you approve through your own brokerage, with mechanical risk gates on every order.

Is execution riskier than advice-only?

Execution adds responsibility, which is why the structure matters. With Tengu your assets never leave your own regulated broker, every order passes risk gates, and nothing executes without your approval, per trade or under a strategy mandate you set.

Can I disconnect Tengu from my brokerage?

Yes, at any time. Access is permission-based and revocable from either side. Revoking it cuts Tengu off and leaves your accounts and holdings untouched at your broker, because Tengu never held them in the first place.

Keep learning